Aprender español XI: Carnada 010

Aprender español X: Carnada 009
Aprender español XII: Carnada 011
Eliza Fanshaw supera el miedo a la muerte con filosofía.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

PAGE 10 (Four panels)

Panel 1: Still in the same apartment where the interview is taking place, but Eliza is now on tiptoes taking a heavy book down from a a high shelf.

Unseen interviewer (1): Seriously, aren’t you afraid?

Translation (1): De verdad, ¿no tienes miedo?

Eliza (2): I have something to make the fear go away. Have you heard of the Roman poet Lucretius?

Translation (2): Tengo algo para alejar el miedo. ¿Has oído hablar del poeta romano Lucrecio?

Panel 2: Close-up around some text, the following lines from Lucretius’s De rerum natura, set in a very old typeface or (better if possible) as medieval manuscript: “respice item quam nil ad nos ante acta vetustas/temporis aeterni fuerit, quam nascimur ante./hoc igitur speculum nobis natura futuri/temporis exponit post mortem denique nostram.

CAPTION – ELIZA NARRATING (3): He explains that we didn’t exist for an eternity before being born, and that wasn’t bad. So why should it be bad once we stop existing?

Translation (3): Él explica que no existimos por una eternidad antes de nacer y que no hay nada de malo en eso. Entonces, ¿por qué habría de malo en dejar de existir?

Panel 3: Eliza, now sitting cross-legged in her big wicker chair. She has the large book she brought down in Panel 1 resting open on her lap. She’s pointing down at something on a page.

Unseen interviewer (4): And you buy that?

Comment (4): “And you buy that?” is an idiom in American English, the literal meaning of which is “Do you really believe that?”

Translation (4): ¿Y tú te crees eso?

Eliza (5): It’s what David Hume told James Boswell as Hume was wasting away, about to die. But Hume was calm and even told jokes.

Translation (5): Es lo que David Hume le dijo a James Boswell cuando Hume se estaba debilitando, a punto de morir. Pero Hume estaba tranquilo e incluso contaba chistes.

Panel 4: Eliza looking down at the page of the book open on her lap, reading.

Eliza (6): From Boswell’s account: “I asked him if the thought of annihilation never gave him any uneasiness. He said not the least; no more than the thought that he had not been, as Lucretius observes.”

Comment (6): Eliza is quoting from a real literary work, James Bosewell’s Life of Johnson. If there is a public domain version of the Life in your target language, you are encouraged to substitute its text for your own translation.

Translation (6): De acuerdo con Boswell: “Le pregunté si la idea de la aniquilación nunca le causaba alguna inquietud. Dijo que en lo más mínimo; no más que la idea de no haber existido, como dijo Lucrecio”.

  Carnada (Español/Versión de página larga)
Carnada (Español/Versión deslizante)